Blog

February is an ideal moment for juniors to get intentional about the college admissions process. With senior year approaching, the choices you make now can shape not only where you apply, but how confident you feel as you proceed through the admissions process. Two questions tend to be top of mind: “What really matters in admissions?” and “How do I build a realistic college list?” Let’s tackle both.

What Actually Matters (and What Doesn’t)

Admissions officers review applications in context, looking for evidence that a student has challenged themselves and grown over time.

Course rigor matters more than perfection. Colleges want to see that you’ve taken appropriately challenging courses—especially in core subjects—relative to what your high school offers. An upward grade trend or consistent rigor often carries more weight than a single low grade. A 3.6 in a demanding curriculum may matter more than a 4.0 with limited, safe course choices. Likewise, grades over time beat one standout semester. GPA is important, but so is trajectory. Improvement, resilience, and consistency tell a story that a transcript snapshot cannot.

Depth beats breadth in activities. A long list of clubs with minimal involvement is less compelling than passionate, sustained e commitment to a few interests. Leadership, initiative, or tangible impact—whether in a job, sport, family responsibility, or volunteer role—matters more than an activity’s prestige.

What matters less than families think?

– Chasing “impressive” résumé-padding extracurriculars solely for admissions. Consistent, committed engagement across a few meaningful activities is often valued more than a long, shallow list.

– A “perfect” personal statement (aka the CommonApp essay.) A perfectly polished essay filled with over-the-top vocabulary is less important than a truly genuine one. Admissions officials really want to hear your authentic voice, and may fail to appreciate your essay if it sounds like it was written by a 50–year-old.

Admissions is about context and authenticity, not perfection.

Building a Balanced College List

Strive to build a target college list that reflects both aspiration and realism. A strong college list typically includes:

Reach, or selective admissions schools are those where admission is less likely based on historical data. Reaches are fine—and encouraged—but they shouldn’t dominate your list.

Right or match schools are colleges where your academic profile aligns well with the middle range of admitted students. These are often where you may find the best balance of opportunity and confidence.

Sure or safety schools are universities where admission is highly probable and that you would genuinely be excited to attend, both academically and financially. 

When researching schools, look beyond rankings. Consider:

Academic programs and flexibility. Does the college encourage exploration, or does it expect early specialization? How easy is it to change majors, or add a minor? Look at course catalogs, not just department names. Strong advising and interdisciplinary options may matter more than a program’s title.

Campus culture and advising support. Is the school’s environment collaborative or competitive? Residential or commuter-heavy? Ask how advising works: Are students assigned faculty advisors early? Is there career advising built into the academic experience, or is it optional and understaffed?

Class size, location, and learning environment. Introductory class sizes, discussion sections, and faculty accessibility shape day-to-day life. Location matters too—urban campuses often offer internships during the school year, while rural campuses may foster tighter-knit communities. Neither is better, but one may suit you more.

Outcomes: internships, graduate school placement, employment. Look for data on internships, job placement rates, and graduate or professional school outcomes. Where do students go after graduation? Are alumni networks active and accessible? Outcomes can be a better indicator of value than selectivity alone.

A balanced list is not about maximizing prestige; it’s about optimizing personal fit and options. In fact, research shows that student engagement—taking advantage of opportunities—is more indicative of future success than the ranking of the institution. Developing a framework for what you want, and not what others think, is what really matters.

Early spring of junior year is an ideal time to start researching colleges and developing the target list of schools you plan to apply to. But before you begin conjuring a list of reaches, rights and safeties, stop for a moment to consider why you want to go to college, and what you hope to accomplish in the next four years.

While college is the natural next step for most, pause and reflect on what makes you tick and what really matters to you. College is a major investment, for you and your family. How do your intellectual interests align with potential college majors, and how does study in a particular major prepare you for your eventual career? This should inform the colleges you decide to apply to, and this intention should in turn shape the application that you submit. 

If your career aspirations do call for a college degree, the next step is to research colleges beginning with your academic area(s) of interest. For example, if you are committed to a career in engineering or computer science, colleges that focus on technology, such as Wentworth Institute of Technology, Worcester Polytechnic Institute (WPI) or Rochester Institute of Technology (RIT) might be a fit for you. If you plan to pursue a career in sales, marketing, finance, or other business roles, a liberal arts education which includes core curriculum requirements across a range of subjects may be for you.

For some, an undergraduate education is the necessary preparation to enter the workforce, whether you plan on being a software developer or a social media marketer. For others, an undergraduate degree is a required stepping stone to graduate education, whether you want to be a college professor, government economist or medical doctor. On the other hand, if you are planning to join your parent’s construction or catering business, how will a college degree help you? For some, training in a trade or an apprenticeship might be a better fit.

Some colleges are especially well-regarded in a specific academic area. For example, New York University (NYU) and University of Southern California (USC) are well-known for filmmaking, while the University of Chicago is highly regarded for economics. If you are interested in game design, you might instead consider Georgia Institute of Technology, Northeastern University, or Drexel University. George Washington may be a target college if you’ve always dreamed of working for a Washington D.C. non-profit, while Oregon State University may be the perfect school if you are excited about a career in marine biology. Research which universities have robust departments dedicated to your favorite subject.

Other criteria you may want to consider when narrowing your college list include school size, region of the country, and setting: rural, suburban, urban. Do you relish the idea of sitting in an auditorium with 400 freshman for introductory chemistry, and then joining 40,000 raucous classmates at a Saturday football game? Or do you value interacting directly with a professor in a small class of 25 peers, and hiking in the woods with a few friends on the weekend? Are you eager to get out of your hometown, and experience another part of the country, or do you want to be within a half-day drive of home?

Next, put yourself in the shoes of the admissions official. They will be evaluating your high school transcript, GPA, and standardized test scores when considering whether you can succeed academically at their university. Use the intercepts in SCOIR or Naviance to better understand whether a target school is a reach, right, or a safety for you. For example, if your SAT or ACT score and GPA are below 25% for the college’s current freshman class average, the college is a reach for you. A college with an acceptance rate below 9% is also typically a reach for everyone. If you are at or above the 50% for both standardized test score and GPA relative to a school’s current freshman class, that may be a right for you. A safety is a school where your GPA and test scores are at or above 75% of the school’s current class.

If the target university is a state school, such as University of Maryland, Ohio State or University of Michigan, be aware that the school will pull two-thirds of their incoming class from students within the state. College admissions officers also review your participation in extracurricular activities and service in evaluating how you might contribute to student life on campus. Accomplished athletes or performing artists should be in contact with the coach or conductor at target institutions, if they have not already been in contact with you.

Admissions departments strive to assemble a diverse class of students who hail from across the U.S. and around the world. Colleges almost always have more qualified applicants than they can admit, and this is particularly true for schools that are popular among your classmates. For example, if you and 50 of your classmates are applying to, for example, Tufts University, the school is likely to accept 5-10 students, even if 20 from your school are qualified to attend. Given this unfortunate reality, your probability of acceptance might be higher at a school with similar admissions standards in another region of the country.

With more than 4,000 universities in the U.S. to choose from, you can afford to be a little bit like Goldilocks, and find a college that is ‘just right’ for you.

Need guidance tailoring your target school list or crafting your personal statement essay? Contact www.Admit.Fit at (781) 237-7770.